The Madlanga Commission has denied ANC member Sulieman Carrim’s request to testify behind closed doors, despite claims of death threats ahead of his appearance. Commission chair Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga stated that the reasons for the denial would be provided during a break, meaning Carrim will have to testify before the commission in an open hearing.
Testimony Details
Carrim is due to testify about allegations linking him to controversial businessman Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala and a R360 million tender awarded by the South African Police Service (SAPS). Previous witnesses told the commission that Carrim used his political connections within the ANC to help Matlala secure the contract, with testimony also alleging that Carrim received kickbacks linked to the deal.
Those claims are expected to be tested when Carrim takes the stand, with the commission’s evidence leader, advocate Adila Hassim, having opposed the request for a private hearing. Hassim argued that secrecy would not significantly improve Carrim’s safety, stating that Carrim’s role in the matter is already widely known, meaning confidentiality would have little practical effect.
Concerns Over Safety
Hassim noted that although the commission has allowed eight witnesses to testify partly in camera, those witnesses were not public figures. Carrim, she said, is a well-known political figure and the contents of his statement have already been largely discussed in public proceedings. Some details also surfaced during Carrim’s unsuccessful legal challenge against his subpoena in the Johannesburg High Court last month.
The following are some key points regarding the commission’s decision:
- Carrim’s request for a private hearing was denied due to concerns that secrecy would not significantly improve his safety.
- The commission has allowed eight witnesses to testify partly in camera, but those witnesses were not public figures.
- Carrim is expected to testify before the commission on Monday and Tuesday.
Meanwhile, the commission has confirmed that the suspended Crime Intel head, Maj-Gen. Richard Shibiri, will return to the hot seat to testify. The Madlanga Commission is expected to provide brief written reasons for its decision on Monday.
